Midnight Whispers
QAF Brian and Justin Fanfiction
Reviews For Why Not With Me
Reviewer: Naughty_teaspoon (Signed) · Date: May 17, 2019 04:21 PM · On: Why Would He?

I want to punch Michael now. 

Reviewer: Naughty_teaspoon (Signed) · Date: May 17, 2019 08:20 AM · On: Why Would He?

I want to punch Michael now. 

Reviewer: SunshineSally (Signed) · Date: May 12, 2015 01:45 AM · On: Why Would He?

I want to cuddle Justin so bad, and Brian - I am so proud of him (hugsssssss)

Reviewer: JTSecrets (Signed) · Date: October 24, 2009 11:20 PM · On: Why Would He?

I have to read on to see where this is going now.



Author's Response:

This chapter brings up a topic that I'll be bringing up in future chapters that's been "in the works" for a long time. Well, it's been in my mind, not on paper, but still!

Reviewer: Kitty_Ballou (Signed) · Date: August 23, 2009 10:01 PM · On: Why Would He?

*takes a deep breath*

It's so hard to read about Brian + that he doesn't know about what Michael DIDN'T do! *sighs*

And I am too curious - have to go and read the next chapter!!



Author's Response:

That part is very sad; to think he's going around not knowing how people should be treating him. 

There is going to be more on this topic later on with Dr. Stevenson. 

 

Reviewer: Suse (Anonymous) · Date: August 20, 2009 10:17 AM · On: Why Would He?

“No….Why would he?”  That line says it all about "Mikey". Another great chapter!



Author's Response:

:) Thanks! I hope you'll like how the next chapters deal with that issue -- it's such a complicated one! :)

Reviewer: Annjeela (Signed) · Date: August 20, 2009 09:03 AM · On: Why Would He?

Pure angst (except for the start, of course).  Gotta love it.

I'm hoping that the doctor can alleviate the unreasonable guilt Justin's feeling and lower the pressure on him.  Brian's life hanging on his staying/going isn't a happy place to be.

Excellent writing, as ever.



Author's Response:

Thank you so much! I had a feeling angst-lovers would be happy with these chapters! 

Dr. Stevenson is going to have a big session on guilt with Justin and Brian both and hopefully start to get them straightened out, because you're right -- it's not a pretty place o be at all. 

Thanks again for the lovely review! :)

Reviewer: scrub13 (Signed) · Date: August 20, 2009 06:20 AM · On: Why Would He?

Damn, you've grabbed Brian's attempted suicide from season one by the throat and are tearing Brian's emotions wide open. And that's a really good thing.
i always hated that quote from Michael "You're Brian-fucking-Kinney and you'll always be young and beautiful". The only people who stay young and beautiful are those who die young. Not exactly something you say to someone who just attempted suicide and so stupid on Michael's part.

Michael treated the scarfing incident as a Brian being Brian, not a cry for help. I really think you are the first to really connect all that happened to Brian's angst from that time period and focus on how his friends actions at his birthday and reactions to his job  offer contributed to Brian's feelings that he's worthless and didn't have anything to live for. So sad that Justin's innocence and exitement at asking Brian to go to his prom made it worse.

Justin's anger at Brian, Lindsey and other members of the family may be a real part of their joint reovery. There's been so much that people have hidden from him for various reasons. they treat Brian like the "asshole", while treating Justin like an innocent babe who can't deal with life or the truth. He's been lied to and manipulated by just about all of them.

Vic, Emmett, and Ted(in seasons 4 and 5) may have been their only true friends.



Author's Response:

I'm so happy that you feel like the whole "suicide" thing is playing out in a believable way. I was just terribly struck by the hopelessness of that scene, and the more thought I gave to it, the more heartbreaking I found the whole episode. 

You're totally right -- I mean, it is only those who die young who stay that way! And who the hell calls someone who just was hanging themselves 'pathetic'? I mean... I know Mikey was scared but come on... 

I think you have an interesting point about the rest of everyone. I don't know how much I'll be able to go into it all, but I am definitely thinking about it.

I know...I wish Vic could be alive for my story... *sad*. I think Emmett and Ted will be of a help soon, and Ben, too. :)

Thank you so much for the thoughtful review! :)

Reviewer: kinneydu (Anonymous) · Date: August 20, 2009 02:21 AM · On: Why Would He?

Another great chapter.  I was gobsmacked by your insight into Mikey's part in the scarfing incident.  I never even considered that Mikey should possibly have done more - perhaps talked more to Brian about his feelings, even encouraged him to possibly see someone, that sort of thing.  But when you wrote that chapter it just became all clear.  Does that make sense?  Anyway, thank you for giving us this story.



Author's Response:

It makes sense! I'm just glad the chapter makes sense... I never thought about it a lot until I really started seeing it as a real attempt, then it's like "Okay, Mikey....are you seriously leaving for the other side of the country right now?" I mean, at least he comes back for the bashing -- but still... seeing Brian like that, after a suicide attempt -- I would be... a lot more than concerned.. . 

Thank you SO much for reading and reviewing!! I hope you'll like how the "Mikey part" plays out in the next few chapters. :)

Reviewer: Michelle (Anonymous) · Date: August 20, 2009 01:58 AM · On: Why Would He?

Another extremely well written chapter. I like where you're taking the story with Mikey as well because ...I don't know, maybe it's just me but if I found someone who I claim is my "best friend" in the midst of a suicide attempt, I don't think I could just give them a speech about how much I love them and then leave. I feel that situation requires way more attention and involvement. Luckily Justin and Dr. Stevenson realize this!

"I don’t know anymore. I just don’t know if I can let this go on. If I can let Justin keep coming to these fucking sessions. And keep finding out all these things that put these damned ideas in his head."

Oh god, do I sense some dark foreshadowing? Oh Brian... he's so consumed with blaming himself for everything that he can't accept that for as guilty as he may feel, others have the same reaction. 

Fantastic chapter, can't wait for more!



Author's Response:

! Thanks so much for the review!! :) 

You picked out a great quote... Brian is seriously feeling guilty at this point that he has Justin going through all this. We'll have to see how he reacts to this feeling... 

As for Michael, it's sure a complicated issue that will take a while to discuss... it starts in the next chapter. 

I really hope you'll like the way it all turns out! 

Reviewer: BlindDreamer (Signed) · Date: August 20, 2009 12:17 AM · On: Why Would He?

Good ol Mikey, your my best friend, but when I find u hanging yourself I'll buy whatever crap you're spewing and go about my life,ugh. I could see him delaying telling anyone because of the bashing, but he obviously wasn't concerned at all since he was already boarding the plane to move to wherever with Dr. Dave before he even knew about the bashing. Obviously Brians actions that night weren't the same as his usual fare of drinking and whatnot with anonymous tricks, he was alone and he was in pain and his "best friend" was not mature enough to handle that, so he put it out of his mind.

I really like that even in Brians therapy sessions u have Justin recognizing his own part in Brians emotional problems, like with the death day party. Too many people write Brian off as the asshole and make Justin an angel, no matter that he hurt Brian probably worse than Brian could hurt him.

I really love your portarayal of Dr. Stevenson and the way he instinctivly knows when Brian is not ready to talk about something and backs off.

Overall I loved it! the next time Justin sees Michael its gonna be hard to explain where all that anger is coming from,lol.



Author's Response:

I think you make a really interesting point about Justin's ability to hurt Brian. I'm inclined to agree with you, just because Justin has so many more effective support systems -- his mother, Daphne, his art, minimally. Brian on the other hand... Also, I think Justin has a better understanding of relationships in general and would at least have a better understanding. I think Brian lacks that... 

Also -- you're right. I mean, Michael was still totally ready to fly across the country. I am sure taht he does care, but I don't think he grasps the depth of what Brian felt, and he couldn't respond in the right way. 

Ah yes. Justin's anger at Mikey. You'll see that in the next chapter. :) *spoiler!* 

Thank you SO MUCH for the review! You bring up many good points for me to think about. :) Hope you'll enjoy the next one!

Reviewer: sjmpets3 (Signed) · Date: August 19, 2009 11:15 PM · On: Why Would He?

omg. brian thinks michael is his best friend, as michael spouts all the  time and yet michael does nothing to try and get him the help he needed. i don't blame justin for his anger. really, how stupid is michael?

i now can understand brian's adversion to committment and marriage if he relates it to the fake front his parents put on for the outside world.

i hope brian is able to keep his promise to justin that it will never happen again. the morning was so tender and loving. it was nice to see them like that. 

i look forward to this story and it's updates. it's mavelous. so deep and painful and loving and tender. you can tell that deep down the want to heal is there, for both of them.



Author's Response:

I'm really glad you mentioned that part about Brian's aversion to commitment. That was something that I hoped would make sense -- it makes sense to me, but it doesn't always translate. 

The morning...yeah...I think Brian was sort of trying to use the tender sex to be able to then say what he wanted to say afterwards. And what a way to wake up!!!

I hope Brian keeps his promise, too. I know he really wants to.

I'm very touched thta you like the story so much..... that's everything I was aiming for.... Thank you so much! *big smile!!!!*

 

Reviewer: MissMoe (Anonymous) · Date: August 19, 2009 10:43 PM · On: Why Would He?

omgomgomgomgomg....I can't believe I didn't even realize that. Now I am wondering, Why didn't Mikey tell anybody? For a bestfriend, it really looks like he did a shit job of it. Phew, so many revelations, I am so excited to read your next chapter. Each chapter just builds up to a new discovery. When you mentioned angst, boy did you mean it, poor Justin is being pulled through all this. He's a strong person but it's so sad when he gets emotional. I'm still reeling from the Mikey stuff...wow. Great chapter!



Author's Response:

Thanks so much! I'm glad you liked the chapter and that the revelations seem plausible. The next chapter is less angsty, though I'll be dealving back into the whole B/J guilt-and-suicide-related issues soon after that. 

I'm thrilled that the chapters are able to pull you in that way. :) I hope you'll like the next one as well. :)

Reviewer: templeton_ma (Anonymous) · Date: August 19, 2009 10:10 PM · On: Why Would He?

I really really love Dr Stevenson's reaction in this chapter. He was so startled by what he heard and saw, that Brian was really cluelss about how wrong the situation is (especially regarding Mikey). The Doc is so compassionate. I really like him a lot.

I also like your logic and imagination as you paint us a picture and reveal it skilfully how Brian's upbringing affected every single aspect of his adult life. I have never seen any fics which can touch on Brian with such depth and breadth like this.

And I almost forgot about the casket scene. You really nailed this one. Perfect placement in the plot. Bravo!

And I laughed so loud when the Doc dropped the bottle of water. You nailed it again but making Brian so in character:

"And Brian’s continuing as if he just explained 4-way stops to a seven-year-old."

 



Author's Response:

Thanks so much! I'm so glad that you like the way this chapter played out at the doctor's... Dr. Stevenson's education continues....! 

I was always just struck in that scene with Ben and Michael's neighbors at how purely uncomfortable Brian is. I started wondering what might cause him to be so much against the whole "marriage" thing, and so emotional about it.... Between that and how little experience Brian has with any kind of relationships -- no other boyfriends, no good parental/adult relationships other than possibly Debbie, I mean... He's just operating without a lot of prior knowledge that most people would take for granted. I hope that is what comes through in the story... Thank you so much...I feel a lot for Brian... 

 

*laughs* Yeah, Brian is Brian, always. :) I could just imagine the doc dripping wet and Brian going on as if autoasphxiation was the same sort of topic as yeserday's weather. :)

 

Reviewer: Gina Marie (Signed) · Date: August 19, 2009 10:10 PM · On: Why Would He?

Great chapter.  A few things about Brian's 'thinking' bothers me.  In the beginning he tells Justin as long as "I have you"  he won't ever be in 'that' place again. Ouch. Lot of responsibility on Justin.   Kind of like the demented partner telling his/her lover that they'll kill themselves if they ever leave.   That's not a good enough reason for Brian not to attempt suicide again, and it's not fair to Justin to hold that kind of responsiblity.  What if down the road Justin wants to leave?  he wouldn't cause he'd have the guilt that if he did, Brian might do something stupid.  NO, I don't like Brian feeling that way.

I'm not sure why the doc and Justin are freaked about what Mikey did either.  Should he have told someone?  Maybe he would have if Justin didn't get bashed that very same night.  Thoughts of what Brian did earlier I'm sure flew out of his head, and I believe that Mikey believed that Brian was just being his reckless self.  Lets not forget Mikey's known Brian a VERY long time. He's use to Brian drinking and drugging to excess. Scarfing would be in character for Brian. He's always lived dangerously.  Going home with strange men who could have killed him, or slipped him a drug while he wasn't looking.   It could have happened. he was always high when he went home or took tricks homes. Often he didn't even remember the previious evenings events like what he did, or who he fucked. Everyone knew this about him, including Justin. So Mikey witnessing a sexual act that Brian did that almost gone bad wouldn't be shocking to him.  And he did yell at Brian that one day he was going to get himself killed. A speech he's said before, as Debbie has said, and Lins I'm sure. 

Sorry for the long comment, but I just don't see the 'shocked' reaction from Justin as real.  The Doc, yeah, he's an outsider, but from Justin, no. He of all people knew how dangerously Brian lived.  He witnessed Brian going home with a total stranger fucked up out of his mind and he did nothing.  He did pretty much what Mikey did, told him "you don't know him, he could kill you" or something like that. Point is he warned him, then let him go off wiht that guy. Mikey warned Brian, and then Brian promised him he wasn't trying to kill himself, that he just went a bit too far in a sexual act.

Ok, I'm off my soapbox now. Obviously great chapter! And I don't want to end with out mentioning how fucking HOT that openign scene was!  Whew!

Lots to consider in this chapter.  Great update.



Author's Response:

I know... I think Brian's just trying to say he gets what Justin means by being "partners" but... he may be taking things a little too far. We'll have to see how Justin feels about that.... You make a very good point. 

I think Justin is shocked not so much by Brian's behavior, but because he is starting to see more of his own role and he's feeling a lot of regret. I think Justin's feeling like he was too self-involved in a way and missed warning signs that he feels now (in retrospect) that he should have seen. And I think he's sad for Brian for his lack of support.

I think you're right about the general recklessness of Brian's behavior, and people do talk to him about that... I think maybe I will put this in. The concern though is that no one tries to find out what feelings or problems are underlying his behavior. I'm going to try to have Dr. Stevenson address some of this with him, especially now that I'm thinking more about it, so thank you so much for your thoughts on this topic.

*So happy you liked the opening scene!* :) :) Great way to wake up, huh? :)

Reviewer: Marny (Signed) · Date: August 19, 2009 09:29 PM · On: Why Would He?

OMG please update soon, grrr now I have to wait patiently.

Do you have more B/J stories to read?
* kisses *



Author's Response:

*big smile* 

I update every day. :) And patience is a virtue. *big smile* 

*feeling a little like a tease*... I do have a few more B/J stories... but they're not published anywhere. *evil smile*  I'm sorry about that. Someday I will put up more, probably only when this is done.

*kisses back* 

Thanks so much for reading and your enthusiasm!

Reviewer: Minoloushe (Anonymous) · Date: August 19, 2009 09:28 PM · On: Why Would He?

I am now sufficiently recovered from my angst wallowing to actually think a little more about chapters 21 and 22! While I certainly don’t think Justin is responsible for Brian’s suicide attempts, those chapters help assuage my dislike of Justin. He’s forced to confront the reality of Brian and certain aspects of his own behaviour.

Love that you mentioned the “Death Day Party”!!!

My feeling has always been that Michael had a good suspicion of what’s going on in 122 but simply doesn’t have the maturity or strength of character to do much of anything about it. The reaction of Dr Stevenson is perfect; it’s heartrending to think that the only help or comfort Brian receives from his best friend, the person who is supposed to know and love him most, is “you’ll always be young, you’ll always be beautiful”….in that one comment Michael effectively chooses his illusion of Brian over the real person.

Michael just can’t let go of his make-believe, life-sized Brian doll.

 

It also makes me think of Lindsay’s casual, throw-away remake in a later episode about Brian nearly killing himself on his last birthday….she certainly didn’t seem too concerned either….

 

Your writing is just so very, very good.



Author's Response:

You're right! I wasn't even thinking about Lindsay a lot -- I sort of was, but you're totally right... even she's not even much more concerned. It makes me wonder what would make them concerned.

I love the way you put that -- Mikey choosing the illusion over the real Brian. That's perfect.

I think that's mostly where Justin's emotions are at the end of this chapter -- regret, a lot of regret, and realizing what it almost cost him. 

Thank you so much for your thoughts and you are just way too kind!! :)

Reviewer: BluvsJ (Anonymous) · Date: August 19, 2009 08:43 PM · On: Why Would He?

MMMMMMMM.... what a lovely way Brian woke Justin up in the morning... the session was amazing ...it covered so much background of all the events that led up to the.."Scarfing".. it also revealed how stupid Mikey really was (is) to not even mention any of what he saw to anyone.. or even try reaching out to find out what was really wrong with his "Best" friend......  I must say that reading a new chapter of this story everyday... "Almost" makes up for not being able to watch QAF every week... Thanks...



Author's Response:

*smiles about the morning wake-up...if one has to be gotten up early....!! * 

I think you're absolutely right -- I mean, Mikey tried to comfort him in a way, but never really asked even "hey, what's wrong?" or anything. That's just...unimaginable, considering that Brian might've been dead had he gotten there like 5 minutes later. 

 

I'm sorry you don't get to watch QAF as often as you like! I'm glad the story helps with that!

Reviewer: edom (Signed) · Date: August 19, 2009 02:12 PM · On: Why Would He?

The morning was hot, and loving :)

I loved the way you made Justin realize what had been going on around that time. I think they will have to work out all the guilt they are both feeling if they want to move forward, it's clouding their judgment.

I can understand why Dr. Stevenson is so shocked by that whole scarfing scene, it's really very traumatic. I hope he somehow manages to convey to Brian that Mikey has been horribly wrong in not doing anything more than what he did, and I hope that Justin goes of on him, Michael I mean.

As usual a great chapter.



Author's Response:

I'm so glad that the morning scene wasn't totally lost in the angst -- I was trying my best to capture the sort of "ice cream kiss" spirit (damn I just love that scene so much) and continue it... Anyway. :)

I think you're right -- their judgment is really starting to be impacted. I think Dr. Stevenson is going to have to have sort of a heavy hand and help them out on this one.

Dr. Stevenson is still being educated by Brian's lifestyle, and then adding the temendous trauma as you said. No wonder he's all wet...!

To me, that's the saddest part of Mikey's response -- it highlights for me how shallow Brian's whole level of support is, and I start to wonder about how Brian expects to be treated by those who love him. That's what I most wanted to convey with Brian's innocence at the end of this chapter -- I think correcting this is possible... I hpoe Dr. Stevenson knows how! 

As for Justin... a pretty dramatic scene is forming in my mind with him, Michael and Ben. So that will be in a chapter coming soon! 

Thanks so much for your thoughts -- it's invaluable to me to see how the story is coming across in this way and the support encourages me to keep it going. Thank you!!! :)

Reviewer: nicole (Anonymous) · Date: August 19, 2009 02:11 PM · On: Why Would He?

Just wanted to let you know that I am absolutely loving your story. I am always looking forward toward your next update. I have to say that your story could definately be one way to interpret some of the events that take place in the series. I hope that you hve a discussion regarding the type of friend Mikey is to Brian. Can't wait to see where you go with Mikey. Good luck with your upcoming chapters.



Author's Response:

New Reviewer!?! YES! :) :) :) 

Thanks so much for taking the time to comment; readers' comments make such a big difference to me and really motivate me to make the story as good as I can possibly make it. 

I hope everything goes okay with Mikey -- it's a complicated subject, and I don't really just want to bash him... 

Thanks again very much! I hope you'll enjoy the next chapters, too!

Reviewer: Cait (Anonymous) · Date: August 19, 2009 01:57 PM · On: Why Would He?

Worth the wait!  The beginning was so tender and lovely and I'm glad that Mikey and all of his enabling of Brian's destructive behavior is about to be adressed.  Fabulous.



Author's Response:

You're my 200th Reviewer!!!!!!!!! Thanks so much!!! Unfortunately, no prize seems forthcoming, except for my most enthusiastic THANK YOU!!!!! :) :) 

 

I'm so glad it was worth the wait! A bunch of my plans for the day got all messed up, then I got caught in a huge downpour (I mean I walked 2 blocks *with an umbrella* and came out looking like I'd spent 2 minutes fully clothed in the shower) which caused me to miss the train I was trying to catch. The whole time I kept thinking, "Why did I ever say when I would be posting the next chapter!?!"

Anyway, enough with my excuses/reasons! 

*happy that people remembered the beginning, too!* 

Yes... Mikey. Such a complicated subject...I hope I can make it turn out okay. 

Thanks so much again!! 

You must login (register) to review.