Midnight Whispers
QAF Brian and Justin Fanfiction
Reviewer: Predec2 (Signed) · Date: November 25, 2018 02:36 PM · On: Chapter 11: This is Not That Kind of Love Story

Hi, Amanda!  What a thoughtful chapter.  I loved this part: “Rain is good. The earth needs rain. Rain is cuddling up all cozy with tea and a good book. Depression is just fucking overcast, just clouds. No sun, no rain. No nothing.”  That fits my concept of depression very well.  It's a lack of joy IMO.  That is the worst part.  You 'exist,' you don't 'live.'

And I recall how Justin abhorred everyone babying him right after the bashing with all the endearments, but I had never really given a lot of thought to how being called "Sunshine" all the time afterward would create pressure on him to live up to his nickname.  Great exploration of that. 

I always admire writers who can create 3D OC's with their stories, too, b/c I think it adds depth to a plot.  Ana and Tori can see things from an outsider's perspective and be objective to what is going on. I think that's important, as well as Brian's continuing support of his partner.

Still loving this story and will always look forward to reading the updates!  Thanks for posting this on here.  And BTW, I'm glad you feel comfortable on the site. We are very fortunate to have you as a writer. Thank you. :)  ~Kim



Author's Response:

Hi Kim, Thank you as always for your wonderful feedback. I'm glad you feel I'm capturing the experience of depression - for as common as it is, there are so many misconceptions of what it's like to be depressed. 

I hadn't even really thought about the nickname Sunshine until I started writing and thought about if it would make sense to keep calling Justin Sunshine when he's depressed. But there was so much that happened in those moments at the jeep in the prom episode that I thought Brian must have a different perspective. I'm glad I was able to explain it while still keeping Brian in character since of course he wouldn't come right out and say what he thinks. Justin has to do a lot of interpreting for the reader. 

I'm glad you're liking Ana and Tori - having someone outside the Pittsburgh family is very helpful.

I'm loving the MW community and I'm so fortunate to have this encouragement in my writing. 

-A

Reviewer: cullengirl08 (Signed) · Date: November 24, 2018 12:24 PM · On: Chapter 11: This is Not That Kind of Love Story

Yup, Brian can deny, deny, deny all he wants, but he does love Justin.   But its true what was said in this chapter.   None their friends see that Brian has changed, and he has, in many ways.   And if Brian and Justin do decide to move, his friends will be the first ones to give him grief about it.     



Author's Response:

Brian’s denial is what makes him such an interesting character! It’s hard to write because I just want to spell everything out but that’s not him. 

Yeah I still need to figure out what to do about the friends and the move. That’s going to be rough.  

Reviewer: marie-france (Signed) · Date: November 24, 2018 09:17 AM · On: Chapter 11: This is Not That Kind of Love Story

I love more and more Tori and Ana. I hope that even if they go to LA they will stay in the area.

Author's Response:

Thank you! I’m pretty fond of Tori and Ana. I’ll find a way to keep them in the story!

You must login (register) to review.